- 2024-2025 Mike Edwards
- 2023-2024 Andy Jones
- 2022-2023 Ralph Tucker
- 2021-2022 Brian Reeder
- 2021 (Covid) Steven C. Deery Jr.
- 2020 Steven C. Deery Jr.
- 2019 Derrick Brode
- 2018 Andy Hall
- 2016 Phil Pennington
- 2015 Stephen Maichle
- 2014 Joe Morris Jr.
- 2017 Terry Jester
- 2013 Glenn Gillespie
- 2012 Les Warwick
- 2011 Doug Butler
- 2010 Mike Rains
- 2009 John Fox
- 2008 Chuck Snyder
- 2007 Tucker Dempsey
- 2006 James Watson
- 2005 Rodney Marvel
- 2004 Kevin Wilson
- 2003 Michael Rush
- 2001 Jeffery Eisenbrey
- 2000 Grover Ingle
- 1999 Elmer Steele
- 1998 Carroll Jester
- 1997 William Walton Sr.
- 1996 Ted Walius
- 1995 Kenneth Clendaniel
- 1994 Joseph Vattilana
- 1993 James King
- 1992 Raymond Blanchette
- 1991 Jon Townley
- 1990 Clayton Yocum Sr.
- 1989 Willard Betts Jr.
- 1988 William Walton Jr.
- 1987 Ron Marvel
- 1986 David Mast
- 1985 Robert Romig
- 1984 Mike Vincent
- 1983 Charles Boyer
- 1982 George Greenly
- 1981 Willam Higgins
- 1980 J. Allen Metheny
- 1979 Duane Austin
- 1978 Howard Blizzard
- 1977 Bruce Ennis
- 1976 Charles Price
- 1975 C. Bryan Bennett
- 1974 Albert Lane Jr.
- 1973 Francis Dougherty
- 1972 Norman Batchelor
- 1971 Watson (Dick) Green
- 1970 John Smith
- 1969 John Wingate
- 1968 Russell Hayes
- 1967 James Malloy
- 1966 Granville White
- 1964 Louis Amabili J
- 1963 Lewes Evans
- 1962 E. Reynolds Bradley
- 1961 Olin Thomas
- 1960 Ellis Kyttle
- 1959 John Ryan
- 1958 Paul Rambo
- 1957 William Himes
- 1955 Harry Mahan